Skip to content
PR Explained

The Skims Refund and What It Teaches About Brand Backlash

The Skims Refund and What It Teaches About Brand Backlash

Skims offered every buyer a full refund or store credit after its $148 advent calendar of hair ties, keychains and bobby pins set off a brand backlash on TikTok over value. The unboxing videos spread fast, and within days the company was contacting buyers directly.

This is exactly where AI can help. Real-time media monitoring alerts you quickly to online chatter that could be damaging, so you can assess it and respond quickly.

At the end of the day, PR can only spin so much. If the product, in fact, lacks the value, then I think it’s a good move to issue the refunds and get a positive story. And if you’re going to make that refund, it’s a golden PR opportunity that also talks about how much you care about your customers.

What Happened With the Skims Advent Calendar

The calendar promised 12 days of small surprises. According to TODAY.com, the contents include key chains, hair ties and scrunchies, clips, bobby pins and a compact mirror.

FashionUnited reports that the backlash started when creator Kayla Ryan opened the calendar on TikTok and grew more disappointed with each item. “I’m hoping this is a prank and the last one is a $150 gift card for all my money back,” she said. Other shoppers posted their own unboxings, and TODAY.com reported that one video posted on Nov. 5 had drawn more than 47.7 million views by the afternoon of Nov. 7.

Page Six quoted commenters calling the set “junk” and one who wrote that it “should be lawsuit-worthy.” By Nov. 7, the brand co-founded by Kim Kardashian had a response out. A spokesperson acknowledged that “for some, the calendar didn’t meet expectations” and said: “We have personally contacted every customer who purchased the calendar and offered them a choice of a full refund or a SKIMS credit to put towards other products.”

Skims is not the first. In 2021, Chanel faced its own TikTok backlash over an $825 advent calendar that included stickers, magnets and an empty dust bag. Chanel’s president of fashion, Bruno Pavlovsky, told WWD the controversy was “a bit of a shame because it was not what Chanel intended,” and that “in future, we will certainly be much more cautious.”

Why Fast Media Monitoring Matters in a Brand Backlash

A backlash over value usually starts as chatter. One unhappy buyer posts a video, other buyers pile on, and then the entertainment and fashion press writes about the pile-on. By the time a reporter calls, the story has a shape, and you are reacting to it.

The window to act is before that point, and that is the job of real-time media monitoring: an early alert gives you time to assess the chatter and respond.

We built our own AI tools for PR at Prism, including media monitoring, newsjacking and fact checking. Our newsjacking tools run a search for every client before 7 a.m. Eastern, pull the stories from the past 24 hours on each client’s topics and rank them. Speed is the whole point. A tool like that does not make the decision for you. It buys you the hours you need to make a good one.

What to do on Monday:

  1. Monitor the product, not only the brand name. Track product names, your price points and phrases like “worth it,” “scam” and “refund,” across TikTok and review sites as well as the news.
  2. Set an alert threshold. Decide in advance how many posts, views or press mentions trigger a call with leadership.
  3. Name the decision makers now. Know who can approve a refund or credit on a Saturday, before you need them.

The Hard Question: Stand Your Ground or Refund?

I remember when I was doing PR for The Groomsman Suit, an e-commerce brand. One of their customers was threatening them with a negative review and demanding a refund. It was one of those situations where they were like, “Well, we know that we didn’t do anything wrong. This person is clearly just looking to keep the product for free.”

Do you stand up to this person, or do you bow to them and let them write a negative review, when online reviews are your entire currency? For an online brand, that is not an exaggeration. Northwestern University’s Spiegel Research Center found that the purchase likelihood for a product with five reviews is 270% greater than for a product with no reviews.

These are the decisions Skims has to make. On one hand, the brand is so recognizable because of the Kardashians that it can get away with it. On the other hand, you have to look at it from a moral point of view as well as a business point of view.

Four Questions to Ask Before You Decide

I think that’s what people have to weigh. Before you answer a value complaint, put these questions to your team:

  1. Are they right? Read the complaints with an open mind, as feedback rather than an attack.
  2. Did we come up short? Compare what you promised in the listing, the ad and the packaging with what the customer got.
  3. Does the product provide the value? If your own team would not pay that price for it, you have your answer.
  4. Is the negative publicity going to cost more than the refunds? Put a number on both. Refunds have a ceiling. A story that keeps running does not.

If the answers say the customer has a point, a statement alone will not fix it. Skims built its response around a concrete remedy, and the remedy became the story.

Turn the Refund Into a Positive Story

A refund handled well shows customers how much you care about them. It needs to come with a positive PR spin that proves your product always has to have value. If it doesn’t, you honor that.

Here is how to frame it:

  • Lead with the fix. Say what customers can get and how to get it in the first sentence.
  • Acknowledge the gap plainly. Skims said that “for some, the calendar didn’t meet expectations.” That is enough. Do not argue with the people who are upset.
  • Contact buyers directly. Skims said it personally contacted every customer who bought the calendar, so buyers heard about the fix from the company itself.
  • Say what changes next. Skims said customer feedback “will directly shape how we approach future releases.” Then make sure the next release proves it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Skims offer refunds on its advent calendar?

Shoppers posted unboxing videos on TikTok questioning whether the $148 calendar’s hair ties, keychains and other small items were worth the price. Skims said it contacted every buyer and offered a full refund or store credit.

How should a brand respond to a backlash over value?

Monitor the chatter early, decide honestly whether customers have a point, and if they do, lead with a concrete remedy such as a refund or credit. Then explain what will change in future releases.

How can AI help with a brand backlash?

AI-powered media monitoring can flag damaging chatter on social media and in the news quickly, which gives a company time to assess the problem and respond before it hardens into a news story.

The Fix Is the Message

Skims has a name big enough to ride this out. The lesson for every other brand is to hear the complaint early, ask whether it is fair, and if it is, make it right and say so.

We are an award-winning, full-service PR agency, and we are also a digital PR and linkbuilding firm. Our crisis and reputation team helps brands get ahead of a backlash, and we earn the coverage, with backlinks (a clickable link from a news story to your website, which lifts your Google ranking), that drives SEO and AEO: showing up when people search on Google and when they ask AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini. If your brand is facing a backlash, or you want to be ready for one, talk to us.

Keep Reading

Related Posts

Get Started

Want Coverage Like This for Your Brand?

Tell us what you want to be known for. We will show you how earned media gets you there.